Why do calorie apps give different numbers for the same food?
By Lance Hughes, founder of Plategist · Updated 4 November 2026
Because a calorie number depends on two choices made before you see it: which database row stands for your food, and what weight a serve is taken to be.
We make Plategist, one of these apps, so read this with that in mind.
Most AI tools are generative: they write a likely number rather than look one up, which is how they can make a figure up. The figures on this page aren't generated. They're looked up in AUSNUT 2023, the food composition database from Food Standards Australia New Zealand.
Choice one: the serve
AUSNUT has two rows for salted takeaway chips. In one, a large serve is 185 grams. In the other, a large is 545 grams.
| Takeaway chips, "large" | Grams | Energy |
|---|---|---|
| Monounsaturated oil row | 185 g | 1,890 kJ (450 Calories) |
| Blended oil row | 545 g | 5,430 kJ (1,300 Calories) |
Same word, very different bag. An app that hears "large chips" has to pick one.
Choice two: the row
A medium chicken breast is 224 grams in both the grilled and the poached rows. Grilled, it has 77 g of protein. Poached, 60 g. Grilling drives out more water, so the same weight holds more protein.
Rice is the same story the other way: per 100 grams, raw rice has 1,420 kJ (340 Calories) and cooked rice 660 kJ (160 Calories), because cooked rice is mostly water (rice, raw against cooked).
What we do about it
For a meal, Plategist looks each food up in AUSNUT rather than writing a number, and names the row it used; for a packet, it uses the pack's own figures, from its label or barcode. Either way you can correct the amount when ours isn't yours. Two honest tools can still disagree when they've made different choices. The ones to watch are the ones that don't look the number up at all: how AI photo calorie counters work and why chatbots make up nutrition numbers.
Plategist estimates what's on your plate from a photo, then looks each food up in AUSNUT. 14 days free, then a monthly or yearly plan.